Will Morrisey Reviews

Book reviews and articles on political philosophy and literature.

  • Home
  • Reviews
    • American Politics
    • Bible Notes
    • Manners & Morals
    • Nations
    • Philosophers
    • Remembrances
  • Contents
  • About
  • Books

Recent Posts

  • ‘Third World’ Marxism: Fanon’s Polemic
  • The “Garrison State”: How Has It Turned Out?
  • The Leisurely Thomist
  • Islam Historicized: Muhammad Iqbal’s “Reconstruction”
  • Pilgrimages of an Orthodox Christian

Recent Comments

    Archives

    • November 2026
    • October 2026
    • September 2026
    • August 2026
    • July 2026
    • June 2026
    • May 2026
    • April 2026
    • March 2026
    • February 2026
    • January 2026
    • December 2025
    • November 2025
    • October 2025
    • September 2025
    • August 2025
    • July 2025
    • June 2025
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • February 2025
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • March 2024
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • August 2023
    • July 2023
    • June 2023
    • May 2023
    • April 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
    • December 2022
    • November 2022
    • October 2022
    • September 2022
    • August 2022
    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • May 2022
    • April 2022
    • March 2022
    • February 2022
    • January 2022
    • December 2021
    • November 2021
    • October 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • June 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • March 2021
    • February 2021
    • January 2021
    • December 2020
    • November 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • July 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    • September 2019
    • August 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
    • May 2019
    • April 2019
    • March 2019
    • February 2019
    • January 2019
    • December 2018
    • November 2018
    • October 2018
    • September 2018
    • August 2018
    • July 2018
    • June 2018
    • May 2018
    • April 2018
    • March 2018
    • February 2018
    • January 2018
    • December 2017
    • November 2017
    • September 2017
    • August 2017
    • July 2017
    • June 2017
    • May 2017
    • April 2017
    • March 2017
    • February 2017
    • January 2017
    • December 2016
    • November 2016
    • September 2016
    • August 2016
    • July 2016
    • June 2016
    • April 2016
    • March 2016
    • February 2016
    • January 2016

    Categories

    • American Politics
    • Bible Notes
    • Manners & Morals
    • Nations
    • Philosophers
    • Remembrances
    • Uncategorized

    Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

    Powered by Genesis

    ‘Third World’ Marxism: Fanon’s Polemic

    November 18, 2026 by Will Morrisey

    Frantz Fanon: The Wretched of the Earth.  Constance Farrington translation. Preface by Jean-Paul Sartre. New York: Grove Press, 1968.

     

    Sartre begins his prefatory essay with what is likely a true remark: Fanon “does not give a damn whether [Europe] lives or dies.” In one of several moments of wishful thinking, Sartre tells his readers that indeed “Europe is at death’s door.” Fanon rather wants to teach “his brothers” who have emerged or are emerging from European colonialism how “to beat us at our own game.” Proclaiming (with no evidence) that “the Third World finds itself and speaks to itself through his voice”—if so, why would he need to teach it anything?—he points to the “rural masses” as “that veritable reservoir of a national revolutionary army” because if they do not revolt, they will “die of hunger.” What is more, in order to avoid that, it will require “no less than a complete demolishing of all existing structures.” But of course, the worst mass starvation engineered by a post-World War II state occurred in Communist China, at the direction of Mao. Yet Sartre calls for no revolution there, and none occurred, probably because the potential revolutionaries weakened and died.

    “The unity of the Third World is not yet achieved.” Nor will it ever be, he might have added, given the immense differences of regimes and geographic realities that prevail within it. This, from a man who describes Fanon as the person who can get Europeans “to know yourselves objectively,” by which he means in accord with Marx’s ‘scientific socialism’—the “dialectic which liberal hypocrisy hides from you.” Supposedly, colonialists “lay down the principle that the native is not one of our fellow men,” again offering no instances of the claim. But the European settlers are caught in a dialectical contradiction, needing to let their ‘slaves’ live in order to milk them for low-cost labor. Channeling Alexandre Kojève, Sartre asserts that “this mad fury” of the colonized against the colonizers fortifies them; by “their ever-present desire to kill us, by the permanent tensing of powerful muscles that are afraid to relax, they have become men”—winning ‘recognition’ from their tormentors. Then challenging Carl Jung, he announces that this “mad impulse to murder is the expression of the natives’ collective unconsciousness.” Because they have not achieved Marxist consciousness, they continue “fight among themselves,” with a boost from the colonizers’ tactics of divide-and-conquer. But it is now “the moment of the boomerang,” with Europeans as the targets.

    More than fury, more than the quest for recognition, “this irrepressible violence” instances “man recreating himself,” as “only violence” can “destroy” the “marks of violence.” Here we finally see a touch of Sartrian existentialism, his own twist on Rousseau’s call for Man to “rediscover his lost innocence”; to create is to know, as man “comes to know himself in that he himself creates himself.” And, sure enough, Sartre follows Stalin, Enver Hoxha, and Mao in melding (in Marxist terms, synthesizing) scientific socialism with nationalism. Thus, “to shoot down a European is to kill two birds with one stone, to destroy and oppressor and the man he oppresses at the same time: there remains a dead man and a free man; the survivor, for the first time, feels a national soil under his feet.” This new man will be “a different man” than what European man has been, a man “of higher quality.” The Nation “is one with his liberty,” making “tribal dissensions weaken,” having “served no other purpose before than to divert violence against false foes”—a conceit that reveals more of Sartre’s ignorance about the feuds and wars that predated modern colonialism by millennia.

    All of this will be “replaced by socialism,” Sartre bravely and incorrectly predicts. And socialism will triumph in Europe, too, since Europeans themselves are “being decolonized,” that is, “the settler which is in every one of us is being savagely rooted out.” “Our humanism” has been “nothing but an ideology of lies, a perfect justification for pillage,” but it has had its day. The appeal to non-violent resistance made by the likes of Gandhi is worthless; pacifism is really passive-ism. “The fat, pale continent” along with “that super-European monstrosity, North America,” will fall to the now-inverted “ratio of forces” at the command of the colonized; “violence has changed direction.” Fortunately for us, “violence, like Achilles’ lance, can heal the wounds that it inflicted.”

    Well, it didn’t, and often doesn’t. But Fanon does indeed suppose it does. “Decolonization is always a violent phenomenon,” resulting, when successful, in “a total, complete, and absolute substitution” of one ruling group for another, a “kind of tabula rasa” that enables “a whole new social structure” to be “changed from the bottom up.” More, “decolonization is the veritable creation of new men” because “the ‘thing’ which is decolonized,” the much-denigrated, ‘objectified’ colonial ‘subject,’ “becomes man during the same process by which it frees itself.” In the Biblical language of secular apocalypse, “the last shall be first and the first last.” For now, however, “our historical mission is to sanction all revolts, all desperate actions, all those abortive attempts drown in rivers of blood.” That is, Fanon is something of a fool, something of a knave, and an inveterate encourager of folly and knavery in others. To some extent, his blandishments have succeeded, folly and knavery being very real potentials of human beings everywhere and always.

    Third World revolution is possible because in the colonies the dialectic of oppressors and oppressed is stark. In “capitalist countries a multitude of moral teachers, counselors, and ‘bewilderers’ separate the exploited from those in power,” performing the rites of bourgeois mystification. Not so in the colonies, where police and soldiers have “frequent and direct contact with the people,” speaking “the language of pure force,” bringing violence “into the home and mind of the native,” whom Fanon conceives, or pretends to conceive, as a Rousseauian innocent.  The brute and brutalizing force that ‘capitalism’ uses to maintain itself in power there is obvious to all. In Fanon’s Marxist jargon, “In the colonies the economic substructure is also the superstructure.” Rule by violence prevails in “a Manichean world,” in which (he alleges) the native is defined as “absolute evil.” Fanon calls colonial rule “totalitarian,” in a clever rhetorical appropriation of Hannah Arendt’s description of the Maoist sort of regime he admires. “In the colonial context the settler only ends his work of breaking in the native when the latter admits loudly and intelligibly the supremacy of the white man’s values.”

    Supposedly, colonial rule “dehumanizes the native…turns him into an animal.” Since the native “knows that he is not an animal,” he “begins to sharpen his weapons,” readying his return of violence with violence. “Every time Western values are mentioned” in the Third World “they produce in the native a sort of stiffening or muscular lockjaw”; Third-World Man wants revenge. The fact that Marxism is itself a system of Western ‘values’ goes unmentioned by Fanon. As is nationalism, his other ideological prop. Colonial violence finally does the native a great good, however. “After centuries of unreality, after having wallowed in the most outlandish phantoms”—witchcraft, animism, and the rest, instances of what Marxists call false consciousness—the native, “gun in hand, stands face to face with the only forces which contend for his life—the forces of colonialism.” In this confrontation, “the native discovers reality” and “transforms it into the pattern of his customs, into the practice of violence and into his plan for freedom”—true consciousness, materialist rather than ‘spiritual.’ Fanon lauds Nikita Khrushchev’s famous gesture of banging his shoe on the table during a meeting of the United Nations; he “treat[ing] these miserable capitalists in the way that they deserve.” Fidel Castro “sitting in military uniform” at still another U.N. meeting simply “demonstrates…the consciousness he has of the continuing existence of the rule of violence.” Newly independent countries should not adopt the neutralism of (for example) Nehru’s India. They should take the Communists’ side.

    Violence is necessary for colonized and colonizers alike, as “non-violence” in either its Gandhian or Christian form a contemptible illusion, “an attempt to settle the colonial problem around a green baize table.” Violence is not only necessary but effective because guerrilla warfare can overcome the colonists’ technological superiority. Just as important, “the armed struggle mobilizes the people,” “throw[ing] them in one way and in one direction,” sharpening the ‘dialectic’ of struggle. Producing at last a grain of common sense, he observes that “there is no colonial power today which is capable of adopting the only form of contest which has a chance of succeeding, namely, the prolonged establishment of large forces of occupation.” Retreating from this, however, he dismisses the European-American claim of Kremlin direction of the “liberating movements” as a “myth,” which it was, if one takes the direction as somehow absolute or unquestioned. “The so-called free world” suffers from many such illusions, but have no fear: “violence is a cleansing force” and a unifying one, reducing or eliminating tribal feuds. Given his Marxist progressivism, Fanon does not at this point entertain the possibility that such feuds will return, once the colonizers go. To his credit, he will return to that problem.

    Fanon does indeed look ahead. Decolonization has in large measure occurred and its completion is inevitable. “What counts today, the question which is looming on the horizon, is the need for a redistribution of wealth. Humanity must reply to this question, or be shaken to pieces by it.” With this Marxian threat in hand, Fanon declares that “the Third World ought not to be content to define itself in the terms of values which preceded it,” which would seem to preclude the socialism Fanon immediately advocates. As a first step towards it, he demands reparations from the colonizers, recalling Germany’s payments to Israel while failing to mention that many Israelis wanted none of them. The rationale for reparations is simple, if absurd: “Europe is literally the creation of the Third World” because “the wealth that smothers her is that which was stolen from the underdeveloped peoples,” who are “the slaves of modern times.” Such phenomena as the invention of modern science, industrialism, and indeed capitalism and its consequent ‘wealth of nations’ originated in Europe, with no help from the Third World. With such slender facts to bang on, like Khrushchev, Fanon shifts to banging on the table: “If, through lack of intelligence (we won’t speak of gratitude) the capitalist countries refuse to pay, then the relentless dialectic of their own system will smother them,” since their capital will remained “blocked in Europe.” More than a half a century later, we know that that didn’t happen. There was no serious reason to believe it at the time, either, only the wishful thinking of ideologues.

    Having completed his sophistical ‘critique’ of the First World, Fanon turns to the deficiencies of the Third World. In doing so, he rises to cogency. Nationalist parties there do not understand the villages and consequently do not understand how to organize them. They “distrust the people of the countryside,” thereby assuming some of the attitudes of the colonialists. “The unions, the parties, or the government in a kind of immoral Machiavellian fashion all make use of the peasant masses as a blind, inert tactical force: brute force, as it were.” Understandably, during the period of liberation from colonialism “spontaneity is king, and initiative is localized,” as the natives “hold one doctrine only: to act in such a way that the nation may exist.” True, this “doctrine” is “radical and totalitarian,” but one should take care not to mistake tactics for strategy,” to narrow “the art of politics” into “the art of war.” The native’s “consciousness remains rudimentary.” As they progress on their “onward march,” the people then “legislates, finds itself, and wills itself to sovereignty.” As “colonial oppression” breaks down he “realizes” that “he is building up automatically another system of exploitation.” This form of “treason is not national, it is social.” And to be fair, some of the settler colonists sympathize with the natives. “The barriers of blood and race prejudice are broken down on both sides.” If this isn’t understood, independence will bring “nothing save a minimum of readaptation, a few reforms at the top, a flag waving: and down there at the bottom an undivided mass, still living in the middle ages, endlessly marking time.”

    The new sovereign states will have a middle class, but it is “an underdeveloped middle class,” with no experience of ruling either in government or business. This bourgeoisie will continue to peddle raw materials to Europe, which is easier than organizing manufactures. They will define ‘nationalization’ as lining their own pockets, “follow[ing] the Western bourgeoisie along its path of negation and decadence without every having emulated it in its first stages of exploration and invention”—assuming that exploration and innovation has somehow stopped. The result is “neo-colonialism,” which “lacks something essential to the bourgeoisie: money.” In a rare display of wit, Fanon writes that this makes the native bourgeoisie “a bourgeoisie in spirit only.”

    Unfortunately, he immediately retreats to seriousness. “A country that really wishes to answer the questions that history puts to it, that wants to develop not only its towns but also the brains of its inhabitants, such a country must possess a trust worthy political party.” A party—perish the thought that there should be more than one. This party will be “an organism through which [the] people exercise their authority and express their will”—again, one will. The sober realism of Publius need not apply. “All the hopeless dregs of humanity” in the Third World, “all who turn in circles between suicide and madness, will recover their balance, once more go forward, and march proudly in the great procession of the awakened nation.” A march needs leaders. Sure enough, Fanon calls upon “the leaders of the rising,” the revolution, to “realize that the various groups must be enlightened, that they must be educated and indoctrinated, and that an army and a central authority must be created.” The new middle class, the “authentic national middle class in an underdeveloped country” must “repudiate its own nature in so far as it is bourgeois, that is to say in so far as it is the tool of capitalism, and to make itself the willing slave of that revolutionary capital which is the people.” Only if it does that will it avoid the downward spiral of nationalism-ultranationalism-chauvinism-racism-tribalism. “The bourgeois phase in underdeveloped countries can only justify itself in so far as the national bourgeoisie has sufficient economic and technical strength to build up  bourgeois society, to create the conditions necessary for the development of a large-scale proletariat, to mechanize agriculture, and finally to make possible the existence of an authentic national culture”—authenticity being marked neither by feudal landlord-peasant social relations nor by capitalist-proletarian social relations but by egalitarianism guaranteed not by statist socialism but by the all-pervading socialist party. “The masses should know that the government and the party,” the one party, “are at their service.” As experience has shown, ‘leader’ and ‘slave’ do not mesh well.

    Fanon’s example of a sound political party is Algeria’s FLN, which “teach[es] the masses that everything depends on them.” The main thing to be ‘taught’ at this stage is that nationalism must precede “social consciousness.” This, because social consciousness prior to nationalism will be filtered through tribalist claims, which would interfere with both party and governmental organization. For nationalism to pervade the people, it must be “cultural,” as Fanon wants to avoid statism, with its attendant scleroses. In Europe, the modern state preceded nationalism, if not nationhood. Fanon would skip that stage.

    How?  What cultural features will animate this all-pervading political party? While blaming Europeans for the racialist inclinations of some types of nationalism, he claims that Arab and African cultures are broader than that, while at the same time calling it a “historical necessity” for them to “racialize their claims.” This is an early expression of what has become one of the characteristic self-contradictions of ‘Left’ polemicists: to resist ‘White’ racism, one must authorize racism among ‘peoples of color’—without, of course, acknowledging that this too is racism, usually on the grounds that it responds to the prior racism of the ‘Whites.’ Neo-Marxist dialectic presupposes that two wrongs can make a right.

    The enemy of such dialectic is the intellectual who makes no choice between native and European culture, preferring to “gather together all the historical determining factors which have conditioned them and take up a fundamentally ‘universal standpoint.'” But no: in Africa, for example, militants must adhere to “African-Negro culture and to the cultural unity of Africa” by “upholding unconditionally the people’s struggle for freedom”—this, on the assumption that African culture is in fact a unity. “No one can truly wish for the spread of African culture if he does not give practical support to the creation of the conditions necessary to the existence of that culture in other words, to the liberation of the whole continent.” Such “liberation” will require “send[ing] culture along new paths and trac[ing] out entirely new ones for it,” a “new humanism” for the “new humanity.”

    Comrades, “Leave this Europe where they are never done talking of Man, yet murder men everywhere they find them,” a culture that is “running headlong into the abyss.” As for America, it is worse. “Two centuries ago, a former European colony decided to catch up with Europe. It succeeded so well that the United States of America became a monster, in which the taint, the sickness, and the inhumanity of Europe have grown to appalling dimensions.” One may be permitted to think this a touch overwrought.

    But there is hope. Fanon concludes what has been obvious all along, that he is an intellectual European after all. “All the elements of a solution to the great problems of humanity have, at different times, existed in European thought.” Those elements inhere in Marxism and nationalism; their synthesis, “national consciousness,” as distinct from nationalism, “is the only thing that will give us an international dimension.” National consciousness is the product of “philosophic thought,” not mere passion, however useful passion may be at the ‘stage’ of national liberation. This is why the Third World can begin “a new history of Man,” to “try to set afoot a new man.” The modern European notion of the conquest of nature can include the conquest of human nature by the reform of economic, social, and political structures. Marxism is radicalized Baconianism. Fanon tacitly affirms “the supremacy” of some “of the white man’s values,” not coincidentally those of what was then called the ‘Second World,’ the Communist bloc.

    Filed Under: Nations